Losing Solutions Through Division
You'll learn: Why dividing by an expression involving the unknown can accidentally discard valid solutions—and how to recover them.
The Hidden Danger in Division
When solving separable differential equations, we often divide both sides by a function of y, say h(y), to separate variables. But here's the catch: dividing by h(y) is only valid when h(y) ≠ 0. If h(y) can equal zero, we might be throwing away perfectly good solutions!
Why This Matters
Consider the equation:
dy/dx = y²
The "obvious" approach: divide both sides by y², separate, and integrate. But when we divide by y², we silently assume y ≠ 0.
What if y = 0? Substitute back into the original equation:
dy/dx = (0)² = 0
This means y = 0 (a constant function) is also a solution! It's an equilibrium solution where the derivative is zero and the solution never changes. We lost it by dividing.
The Recovery Process
Always check: After separating variables by dividing by h(y), find where h(y) = 0. These give you constant solutions y = c.
Verify each one: Plug y = c back into the original ODE. If both sides equal zero (or match), you've found an equilibrium solution that division discarded.
Example Pattern
For dy/dx = g(x)·h(y):
- Dividing by h(y) assumes h(y) ≠ 0
- Solutions where h(y) = 0 satisfy
dy/dx = 0(equilibria) - These are constant functions that must be checked separately
Key Takeaway: When you divide by an expression containing y during separation of variables, always identify and verify the constant solutions where that expression equals zero—they're valid equilibrium solutions that division eliminates.