The Identity div(curl F) = 0 and curl(∇f) = 0
What You'll Learn
You'll prove two fundamental identities that connect the divergence, curl, and gradient operators—showing that the divergence of any curl is always zero, and the curl of any gradient is always zero.
The Core Idea
These identities reveal deep structural relationships in vector calculus. Think of them as "impossibility theorems":
- No curl field can have divergence — the twisting motion of a curl pattern naturally has no net expansion or compression
- No gradient field can have curl — pure "downhill" flow (gradients) never circulates
These aren't just computational tricks; they're fundamental laws that govern electromagnetic fields, fluid flow, and conservative forces.
Proving div(curl F) = 0
Let F = ⟨P, Q, R⟩. The curl is:
curl F = ⟨R_y - Q_z, P_z - R_x, Q_x - P_y⟩
Now take the divergence:
div(curl F) = (R_y - Q_z)_x + (P_z - R_x)_y + (Q_x - P_y)_z
Expanding: = R_{yx} - Q_{zx} + P_{zy} - R_{xy} + Q_{xz} - P_{yz}
By Clairaut's theorem (mixed partials are equal when continuous), the terms cancel in pairs: = R_{xy} - R_{xy} - Q_{xz} + Q_{xz} + P_{yz} - P_{yz} = 0
Proving curl(∇f) = 0
For a scalar function f, ∇f = ⟨f_x, f_y, f_z⟩.
The curl is: curl(∇f) = ⟨(f_z)y - (f_y)z, (f_x)z - (f_z)x, (f_y)x - (f_x)y⟩ = ⟨f{zy} - f{yz}, f{xz} - f{zx}, f{yx} - f{xy}⟩
Again, by equality of mixed partials: = ⟨0, 0, 0⟩ = 0
Key Takeaway: The identities div(curl F) ≡ 0 and curl(∇f) ≡ 0 follow directly from the equality of mixed partial derivatives, and they guarantee that curl fields are incompressible and gradient fields are irrotational.