Non-Conservative Fields and Counterexamples
You'll learn: How to recognize and understand vector fields where work depends on the path taken, not just the start and end points.
The Core Idea
Not all vector fields are conservative! While conservative fields have path-independent line integrals (work depends only on endpoints), non-conservative fields behave differently: the work done depends on which path you take between two points.
There are two main reasons a field fails to be conservative:
1. Nonzero Curl
If a vector field F has nonzero curl somewhere in its domain, it cannot be conservative. The curl measures "rotation" or "circulation" in the field. Think of a whirlpool: moving through swirling water does different work depending on whether you go with or against the swirl.
Example: The rotational field F(x, y) = 〈−y, x〉 has curl = 2 (nonzero everywhere). A line integral around a circle centered at the origin gives 2πr², but integrating along a radial path from origin to any point gives 0. Same endpoints, different work!
2. Non-Simply Connected Domain
Even if curl is zero everywhere the field is defined, the domain might have "holes." A classic example: F(x, y) = 〈−y/(x² + y²), x/(x² + y²)〉 defined everywhere except the origin. The curl is zero where defined, but integrating around a circle enclosing the origin gives 2π, while a path not enclosing it gives 0.
Analogy: Imagine walking in a field with a pit in the middle. Going around the pit versus avoiding it entirely can require different effort, even if the field itself seems smooth everywhere you can walk.
Key Takeaway: A vector field is non-conservative if it has nonzero curl in its domain OR if the domain has holes (is not simply connected), causing path integrals to depend on the path taken between endpoints.