Verifying Cylindrical and Spherical Jacobians
What You'll Learn
You'll learn how to compute and verify the Jacobian determinants that give us the familiar volume elements r dz dr dθ for cylindrical coordinates and ρ²sin φ dρ dφ dθ for spherical coordinates.
Why Verify These Jacobians?
In the previous lesson, you learned about Jacobians in three dimensions for general transformations. Now we'll verify that the coordinate systems you've been using—cylindrical and spherical—actually produce the volume elements you've been told to trust. This verification bridges theory and practice.
Computing the Cylindrical Jacobian
For cylindrical coordinates, the transformation is:
- x = r cos θ
- y = r sin θ
- z = z
The Jacobian matrix has partial derivatives of (x, y, z) with respect to (r, θ, z):
J = | ∂x/∂r ∂x/∂θ ∂x/∂z | | cos θ -r sin θ 0 |
| ∂y/∂r ∂y/∂θ ∂y/∂z | = | sin θ r cos θ 0 |
| ∂z/∂r ∂z/∂θ ∂z/∂z | | 0 0 1 |
Computing the determinant (expand along the third row): |J| = r
Therefore: dV = r dr dθ dz
Computing the Spherical Jacobian
For spherical coordinates:
- x = ρ sin φ cos θ
- y = ρ sin φ sin θ
- z = ρ cos φ
The Jacobian matrix (with respect to ρ, φ, θ) becomes:
J = | sin φ cos θ ρ cos φ cos θ -ρ sin φ sin θ |
| sin φ sin θ ρ cos φ sin θ ρ sin φ cos θ |
| cos φ -ρ sin φ 0 |
Computing this determinant (requires careful expansion): |J| = ρ²sin φ
Therefore: dV = ρ²sin φ dρ dφ dθ
Key Takeaway: The Jacobian determinant rigorously justifies the volume elements you use in cylindrical (r) and spherical (ρ²sin φ) coordinates—they're not arbitrary, but emerge directly from the coordinate transformation.