Verifying Polar Coordinates Using the Jacobian
You'll learn: How to derive and verify that the area element in polar coordinates is truly r dr dθ by computing the Jacobian determinant.
Why This Matters
You've already been using dA = r dr dθ when integrating in polar coordinates, accepting it as the correct area element. Now we'll prove this isn't arbitrary—it emerges naturally from the change of variables formula through the Jacobian.
The Polar Transformation
The polar coordinate transformation is:
- x = r cos θ
- y = r sin θ
This maps (r, θ) in the uv-plane to (x, y) in the xy-plane.
Computing the Jacobian
The Jacobian matrix contains all first-order partial derivatives:
J = | ∂x/∂r ∂x/∂θ |
| ∂y/∂r ∂y/∂θ |
Let's compute each entry:
- ∂x/∂r = cos θ
- ∂x/∂θ = -r sin θ
- ∂y/∂r = sin θ
- ∂y/∂θ = r cos θ
So our Jacobian matrix is:
J = | cos θ -r sin θ |
| sin θ r cos θ |
The Determinant
The Jacobian determinant is:
|J| = (cos θ)(r cos θ) - (-r sin θ)(sin θ) |J| = r cos² θ + r sin² θ |J| = r(cos² θ + sin² θ) |J| = r
What This Tells Us
The change of variables formula says dx dy = |J| dr dθ. Since |J| = r, we get:
dx dy = r dr dθ
This confirms that the area element in polar coordinates includes the factor r—it's not an ad-hoc rule but a mathematical consequence of how polar coordinates stretch space!
Key Takeaway: The Jacobian for polar coordinates x = r cos θ, y = r sin θ has determinant |J| = r, rigorously verifying that dA = r dr dθ is the correct area element.