Why Positive tabindex Values Are Problematic
You'll learn why using tabindex="1", tabindex="2", etc., creates more problems than they solve and why they're discouraged in modern web development.
The Temptation of Manual Order
At first glance, positive tabindex values seem like a convenient way to control exactly where users tab through your page:
<button tabindex="3">Third</button>
<button tabindex="1">First</button>
<button tabindex="2">Second</button>
But this creates a navigation minefield for users and a maintenance nightmare for developers.
How Positive Values Disrupt Natural Flow
When you use positive tabindex values, you force the browser to completely abandon the natural document order. Elements with tabindex="1" get focused first, then tabindex="2", and so on—regardless of their position in the HTML.
This creates confusing jumps where focus might leap from the bottom of the page to the top, then back to the middle. Screen reader users and keyboard navigators lose their sense of spatial awareness.
The Maintenance Nightmare
Think of positive tabindex like hardcoded line numbers in a document. If you insert a new interactive element, you must:
- Find all existing
tabindexvalues in that section - Manually renumber everything to maintain order
- Test the entire flow again
In large codebases with multiple developers, this becomes virtually impossible to maintain consistently. Someone inevitably forgets to update values, creating broken navigation patterns.
The Better Approach
Instead of fighting document order with positive values, arrange your HTML logically and use tabindex="0" or tabindex="-1" only when needed for custom components or programmatic focus management.
Key Takeaway: Positive tabindex values break natural navigation flow, confuse users, and create unsustainable maintenance burdens—stick to document order and use tabindex="0" or "-1" when necessary.