Implementation Tradeoffs
You'll learn: How to balance the accuracy of cache eviction policies against their performance costs.
The Core Problem
Every cache eviction policy sounds great in theory—LRU gives you the most recently used items, LFU tracks popularity, ARC adapts intelligently. But here's the catch: the smarter the policy, the more expensive it is to run.
Each eviction algorithm has hidden costs:
- Memory overhead to track access patterns (timestamps, counters, history lists)
- CPU overhead to update metadata on every cache access
- Lock contention when multiple threads need to update the same tracking structures
Real-World Tradeoffs
LRU needs a doubly-linked list and hash map, requiring pointer updates on every read. In high-throughput systems, that's millions of tiny operations per second.
LFU must maintain frequency counters and potentially complex data structures to find the least frequent item quickly—even more overhead than LRU.
FIFO just needs a simple queue—blazing fast but accuracy suffers since it ignores access patterns entirely.
Random has nearly zero overhead (just pick any item) but evicts blindly.
Making the Choice
Think of it like organizing your desk:
- A perfectly sorted filing system (LRU/LFU) takes time to maintain but you always find things fast
- A messy pile (Random/FIFO) requires no organization but finding things is hit-or-miss
In practice, many systems choose "good enough" policies. Redis uses approximate LRU that samples a few random keys instead of tracking all accesses precisely—95% of the accuracy at 10% of the cost.
Key Takeaway: The best eviction policy isn't the most accurate one—it's the one that balances cache hit rate improvements against the CPU and memory costs of maintaining that accuracy for your specific workload.