Choosing Between Creational Patterns
You'll learn: How to decide which creational pattern—Factory, Builder, Singleton, or Prototype—best fits your object creation needs.
The Decision Framework
You've learned four powerful creational patterns, but when should you use each one? The key is matching the pattern to your specific creation problem.
Think of it like choosing transportation: A bicycle, car, bus, or airplane all move you from place to place, but each suits different distances, budgets, and circumstances.
Pattern Selection Guide
Use Singleton when:
- You need exactly one instance throughout your application
- Global access is genuinely required (use sparingly!)
- Example: Configuration manager, logging service
Use Factory Method or Abstract Factory when:
- You don't know the exact class type until runtime
- You're creating families of related objects
- You want to isolate object creation logic
- Example: Creating UI components for different platforms (Windows, Mac, Linux)
Use Builder when:
- Object construction involves many optional parameters
- You need to construct complex objects step-by-step
- The construction process must allow different representations
- Example: Building a complex
HttpRequestwith optional headers, body, timeouts
Use Prototype when:
- Creating new instances is expensive (database queries, file I/O)
- You need variations of an existing object
- Object state is simpler to clone than construct from scratch
- Example: Cloning game character templates with predefined attributes
Quick Decision Tree
- Need exactly one instance? → Singleton
- Creating expensive objects to copy? → Prototype
- Many optional construction parameters? → Builder
- Unknown types at compile-time or related object families? → Factory
Key Takeaway: Choose creational patterns based on whether you need instance control (Singleton), flexible type selection (Factory), step-by-step construction (Builder), or efficient copying (Prototype)—match the constraint, not the pattern's popularity.