Course contentsShow
← Security
Lesson 39 of 3,0522. Threat Modeling FundamentalsFree lesson

The Four Key Questions

Learn the foundational questions: What are we building? What can go wrong? What should we do about it? Did we do a good job?

The Four Key Questions

What you'll learn: The simple four-question framework that drives every threat modeling session and keeps security analysis focused and actionable.

The Core Framework

Threat modeling can seem overwhelming—where do you even start? Adam Shostack distilled the entire process into four essential questions that guide you from start to finish:

  1. What are we building?
  2. What can go wrong?
  3. What should we do about it?
  4. Did we do a good job?

These questions form a repeatable cycle, much like the Plan-Do-Check-Act security lifecycle you've already learned, but specifically tailored for threat analysis.

Breaking Down Each Question

What are we building? Before identifying threats, you must understand your system—its components, data flows, trust boundaries, and what you're trying to protect. You can't secure what you don't understand.

What can go wrong? This is where you brainstorm threats. Using your understanding from question one, systematically identify potential security problems. What could an attacker do? What might fail?

What should we do about it? For each threat, decide on a response: mitigate it with controls, accept the risk, transfer it (e.g., insurance), or eliminate the feature causing it. This aligns with your defense-in-depth strategy.

Did we do a good job? Review your work. Did you miss obvious threats? Are your mitigations appropriate? Is your threat model complete for the current system state? This reflects continuous improvement thinking.

Why This Matters

These four questions prevent analysis paralysis. They give you a structured path through threat modeling—not just once, but repeatedly as your system evolves.

Key Takeaway: The four key questions—What are we building? What can go wrong? What should we do? Did we do well?—provide a simple, repeatable framework that transforms threat modeling from an intimidating task into a manageable, systematic process.