When to Nest vs Flatten Routes
What you'll learn: How to decide between nested route hierarchies and flat route structures for clearer, more maintainable routing.
The Decision Framework
Just because you can nest routes doesn't mean you always should. Nesting adds visual hierarchy and shared layout logic, but it also adds complexity. The key is recognizing when that complexity pays dividends.
Think of it like organizing files on your computer: You could put everything in one folder (flat) or create nested folders for categories and subcategories. Nested folders help when items naturally group together and share context. But over-nesting makes navigation tedious—you'd rather have fewer clicks for frequently accessed files.
When Nesting Makes Sense
Choose nested routes when:
- Shared layouts exist: Dashboard pages all need the same sidebar
- Visual hierarchy is clear: Settings → Profile → Avatar feels naturally nested
- Common data flows down: Parent route fetches user data, children display different aspects
- URL structure aids comprehension:
/dashboard/analyticsreads better than/dashboard-analytics
When Flattening is Better
Flatten routes when:
- Routes are unrelated: Blog posts and checkout flow don't share context
- No shared UI exists: Each page has completely different layouts
- Depth harms clarity:
/app/workspace/project/settings/billing/historyis exhausting - Simple URLs suffice: Sometimes
/checkoutis clearer than nesting under/store/cart/checkout
Finding Balance
Many apps use a hybrid approach: nest where layouts naturally share (admin sections), flatten where independence matters (public marketing pages). Evaluate each route group individually rather than committing to one pattern everywhere.
Key Takeaway: Nest routes when shared layouts and logical hierarchy add clarity; flatten routes when independence and simplicity reduce cognitive overhead—the best structure mirrors how users think about your app.