Course contentsShow
← Mathematics
Lesson 2077 of 3,12143. Linear Algebra — Vectors and SpacesFree lesson

Non-Examples and Verifying Vector Spaces

Identify when a set fails to be a vector space by checking which axioms are violated.

Non-Examples and Verifying Vector Spaces

What You'll Learn

You'll learn how to identify when a set fails to be a vector space by systematically checking which axioms are violated.

Why Non-Examples Matter

Just as learning what's not a mammal helps you understand mammals better, seeing what fails to be a vector space sharpens your understanding of the definition. Not every set with addition and multiplication is a vector space—the axioms must all hold.

The Verification Strategy

To verify a set is a vector space, you must check all ten axioms:

  • Closure under addition and scalar multiplication
  • Commutativity and associativity of addition
  • Existence of zero vector and additive inverses
  • Distributive properties
  • Scalar multiplication identities

To show something is not a vector space, you only need to find one axiom that fails.

Common Non-Examples

The Set of Vectors with Positive Components

Consider the set S = {(x, y) : x > 0, y > 0} with standard operations.

Fails closure under scalar multiplication: If you take v = (2, 3) ∈ S and multiply by c = -1, you get (-2, -3), which is not in S. One violation is enough—not a vector space.

The Union of Two Lines Through the Origin

Take S = {(x, 0) : x ∈ ℝ} ∪ {(0, y) : y ∈ ℝ} (the x-axis and y-axis together).

Fails closure under addition: (1, 0) and (0, 1) are both in S, but their sum (1, 1) is not. Not a vector space.

The Set of 2×2 Matrices with Determinant 1

Fails closure under addition: Two matrices with determinant 1 can add to a matrix whose determinant is not 1.

Key Takeaway

To disprove a vector space, find just one axiom violation—typically closure, zero vector existence, or inverse existence are the easiest to check first.