Course contentsShow
← Mathematics
Lesson 1880 of 3,12140. Multivariable OptimizationFree lesson

Identifying Maxima and Minima from Critical Points

Using constraint boundaries, physical reasoning, or comparison of critical point values to classify extrema.

Identifying Maxima and Minima from Critical Points

What you'll learn: How to determine whether a critical point from constrained optimization is actually a maximum, minimum, or neither.

The Challenge After Finding Critical Points

When you've used Lagrange multipliers to find critical points where the gradients are parallel (∇f = λ∇g), you're left with a crucial question: Which of these points is the maximum? Which is the minimum? Unlike the unconstrained case where you had the Second Derivative Test with the discriminant D, constrained problems require different strategies.

Three Practical Approaches

1. Direct Comparison of Function Values

Simply evaluate f at each critical point. The largest value is your constrained maximum; the smallest is your constrained minimum. This is the most straightforward method when you have a manageable number of candidates.

2. Physical or Geometric Reasoning

Often the problem's context tells you what to expect. If you're minimizing distance, negative values are impossible. If you're maximizing volume inside a fixed container, zero volume is clearly minimal. Use common sense about what the function represents.

3. Constraint Boundary Analysis

Check if the constraint is a closed, bounded curve or surface. By the Extreme Value Theorem for continuous functions on compact sets, extrema must exist. If you found all critical points in the interior and on any boundaries, the largest and smallest values among them are your global extrema.

Think of It Like This

Imagine hiking along a mountain ridge (your constraint). The Lagrange method finds where the trail is neither climbing nor descending relative to the terrain—potential peaks and valleys. To know which is which, you either check the elevation at each spot, use logic (valley bottoms can't be higher than peaks!), or know that if you've checked everywhere on this closed loop trail, the highest and lowest readings must be your answer.

Key Takeaway: After finding critical points with Lagrange multipliers, classify them as maxima or minima by comparing function values directly, applying physical reasoning, or confirming all candidates on a closed constraint have been found.