Course contentsShow
← Mathematics
Lesson 1550 of 3,12135. Antiderivatives and the IntegralFree lesson

Comparing Left, Right, and Midpoint Approximations

Analyze which Riemann sum methods overestimate or underestimate area based on function behavior.

Comparing Left, Right, and Midpoint Approximations

You'll learn how to predict which Riemann sum method gives an overestimate or underestimate based on how a function curves.

The Core Idea

When we approximate the area under a curve using rectangles, the choice between left, right, and midpoint sums matters—and the function's behavior tells us which method is most accurate.

The key insight: it all depends on whether the function is increasing or decreasing, and whether it curves upward or downward.

Increasing vs. Decreasing Functions

For a monotonic (always increasing or always decreasing) function:

  • Left sum: Uses the left edge of each interval to set rectangle height

    • If the function is increasing, left rectangles are too short → underestimate
    • If the function is decreasing, left rectangles are too tall → overestimate
  • Right sum: Uses the right edge of each interval

    • If the function is increasing, right rectangles are too tall → overestimate
    • If the function is decreasing, right rectangles are too short → underestimate

The Midpoint Advantage

Midpoint sums typically give better approximations than left or right sums. For functions with consistent concavity, the midpoint method often splits the difference between overestimating and underestimating.

When a function is concave up (curves upward like ∪), trapezoids formed by left and right endpoints lie above the curve, so both left and right sums tend to overestimate. The midpoint catches the curve closer to its actual position.

When a function is concave down (curves downward like ∩), the opposite occurs—both methods underestimate, and midpoint again performs better.

Key Takeaway: For increasing functions, left sums underestimate and right sums overestimate; for decreasing functions, this reverses. Midpoint sums generally provide the most accurate approximation among the three methods.