Comparing Inference Methods: Trade-offs and Use Cases
You'll learn how to choose between exact, MCMC, and variational inference by weighing their accuracy, speed, and practical constraints.
When performing Bayesian inference, you need to compute posterior distributions—but different methods make different trade-offs.
Exact Inference
Accuracy: Perfect—you get the true posterior with no approximation error.
Computational Cost: Only feasible for models with conjugate priors or very small discrete spaces. Scales exponentially with model complexity.
When to Use: Simple models like Bayesian linear regression with Gaussian priors, or toy problems where analytical solutions exist.
Analogy: Like solving a math problem by hand with the exact formula—accurate but only works for simple cases.
MCMC (Markov Chain Monte Carlo)
Accuracy: Asymptotically exact—given infinite samples, you recover the true posterior. In practice, high accuracy with enough iterations.
Computational Cost: Slow. Requires many samples and careful convergence diagnostics. Can take hours or days for complex models.
When to Use: When you need high accuracy and can afford computation time. Ideal for research, critical decisions, or when you have moderate-dimensional problems and need reliable uncertainty estimates.
Analogy: Like exploring a dark room by randomly walking around—eventually you'll map it perfectly, but it takes time.
Variational Inference
Accuracy: Approximate—you get a simplified version of the true posterior (mean-field assumptions often underestimate uncertainty).
Computational Cost: Fast. Uses optimization instead of sampling, scales well to large datasets and high dimensions.
When to Use: Large-scale problems, production systems, deep learning applications, or when you need quick iterations during development.
Analogy: Like sketching a room's layout from the doorway—faster but less detailed than exploring every corner.
Key Takeaway: Choose exact inference for simple models, MCMC when accuracy matters most and you have time, and variational inference when speed and scalability are priorities—accepting some approximation error.