Sampling Strategies for Human Eval
What you'll learn: How to select the right subset of predictions for human evaluation when reviewing all outputs is impractical or impossible.
Why Sampling Matters
Human evaluation is expensive and time-consuming. If your model generates thousands or millions of predictions, you can't manually review everything. The key challenge: how do you pick examples that give you the most insight into model quality?
Think of it like quality control in manufacturing—you don't inspect every single product, but you need a sampling strategy that catches defects reliably.
Three Core Sampling Strategies
Stratified Sampling
Sample proportionally across important subgroups: user demographics, input categories, prediction confidence ranges, or time periods. This ensures you evaluate all segments of your data distribution, not just the majority class.
Example: If 80% of predictions are "easy" cases and 20% are "hard," pure random sampling might miss issues in the harder 20%. Stratified sampling guarantees representation.
Error Analysis-Driven Selection
Focus on cases where your automated metrics (from earlier lessons like classification evaluation, confidence scores, or drift detection) suggest potential problems: low-confidence predictions, disagreements between models, or inputs flagged by drift detectors.
This is targeted inspection—you're sampling where issues are most likely hiding.
Edge Case Focus
Deliberately oversample rare but critical scenarios: minority classes, unusual input patterns, boundary conditions, or newly emerging data types detected by your monitoring systems. These often reveal the most serious model failures.
Combining Strategies
In practice, use a hybrid approach: start with stratified sampling for baseline coverage, layer in error-driven selection for suspicious cases, and always include edge case oversampling for high-risk scenarios.
Key Takeaway: Effective human evaluation sampling balances representativeness (stratified), efficiency (error-driven), and risk management (edge cases) to maximize insight per annotation dollar.