Bandit Algorithm Comparison and Tuning
What you'll learn: How to empirically compare epsilon-greedy, UCB, and gradient bandit methods across different problem characteristics to choose and tune the right algorithm.
The Core Idea
You've learned three major bandit algorithms—epsilon-greedy, UCB, and gradient bandits—but which one should you use? The answer depends on your problem's characteristics. Think of it like choosing the right tool: a hammer works great for nails, but you need a screwdriver for screws.
Key Dimensions for Comparison
Problem stationarity matters most. Epsilon-greedy with constant step sizes handles non-stationary problems well, while UCB assumes stationarity and struggles when rewards drift over time.
Exploration needs vary. UCB provides systematic exploration based on uncertainty, making it excellent when you need guaranteed coverage. Epsilon-greedy is simpler but explores randomly. Gradient bandits shine when you care about relative action preferences rather than absolute values.
Tuning parameters critically affect performance:
- Epsilon-greedy: Tune
epsilon(typically 0.01–0.1) and step sizealpha - UCB: Tune the confidence parameter
c(often 1–2) - Gradient bandits: Tune step size
alphaand baseline choice
Empirical Comparison Strategy
Run multiple algorithms on the same problem with various parameter settings. Track average reward over time and final performance. Test across different scenarios: stationary vs non-stationary, sparse vs frequent rewards, small vs large action spaces.
For example, UCB often outperforms epsilon-greedy in stationary 10-armed bandits, but epsilon-greedy with decaying epsilon may win in non-stationary settings. Gradient bandits excel when action values have large variance.
Key Takeaway: No single bandit algorithm dominates universally; empirically compare epsilon-greedy, UCB, and gradient methods on your specific problem characteristics, and carefully tune their hyperparameters for optimal performance.