Tool Use Accuracy and Correctness
What you'll learn: How to measure whether your AI agent selects the right tools, passes correct arguments, and successfully integrates with APIs.
Why This Matters
When evaluating AI agents, knowing they complete a task isn't enough—you need to verify they used tools properly along the way. An agent might accidentally succeed by brute force or luck while making fundamental mistakes in tool selection or parameter passing.
Core Evaluation Dimensions
1. Tool Selection Accuracy
Did the agent choose the correct tool from its registry? For example, if the task requires searching a database, did it select search_database instead of incorrectly choosing read_file? This measures the agent's understanding of tool capabilities.
Analogy: Like choosing the right utensil—you wouldn't use a spoon to cut a steak, even if you eventually succeed awkwardly.
2. Argument Correctness
Even with the right tool, did the agent pass valid and appropriate parameters? Check:
- Required arguments are present
- Types match the schema (string vs. integer)
- Values are semantically correct (searching for "weather" not "42" as a location)
3. API Integration Success
Did the tool call execute without errors? This includes:
- Proper formatting (JSON structure, escaping)
- Handling authentication if needed
- Respecting rate limits or constraints
Measurement Approach
Compare agent tool calls against ground truth annotations in your benchmark suite. For each task, you should have:
- Expected tool(s) to use
- Expected arguments with acceptable ranges
- Whether the API call should succeed
Calculate precision/recall for tool selection and argument accuracy rates across your test set.
Key Takeaway: Tool Use Accuracy ensures agents don't just stumble to correct answers—they demonstrate genuine understanding of their action space by consistently selecting appropriate tools and calling them correctly.