Course contentsShow
← Machine Learning and Deep Learning
Lesson 1965 of 3,53842. Retrieval-Augmented Generation: FoundationsFree lesson

Indexing Strategies and Trade-offs

Balancing recall, latency, and memory usage when configuring vector indexes.

Indexing Strategies and Trade-offs

What you'll learn: How to balance recall quality, search speed, and memory consumption when choosing and configuring vector indexes for RAG systems.

The Core Challenge

When building a vector database for RAG, you face a three-way tension: you want perfect recall (finding all relevant documents), instant search speed, and minimal memory usage. Unfortunately, you can't maximize all three simultaneously—every indexing strategy makes deliberate compromises.

Think of it like choosing a vehicle: a sports car is fast but expensive and impractical; a truck hauls lots of cargo but burns more fuel; a compact car is economical but limited. Your index choice depends on your priorities.

The Three Dimensions

Recall accuracy measures how many truly relevant documents your index finds. Exact search (brute-force) gives 100% recall but doesn't scale. Approximate methods like HNSW or IVF trade some recall (maybe 95-98%) for massive speed gains.

Latency is query response time. HNSW offers sub-millisecond searches even with millions of vectors, while IVF can be slower but uses less memory. Your application determines acceptable latency—real-time chat needs <100ms; batch processing tolerates seconds.

Memory usage grows with index complexity. HNSW stores full vectors plus graph edges (high memory), while product quantization compresses vectors aggressively (lower memory, slightly worse recall). You must fit within your hardware budget.

Practical Configuration

When using HNSW, increasing M (graph connections) improves recall but increases memory. Raising ef_construction during indexing makes building slower but improves quality. For IVF, more clusters (nlist) speeds up search but reduces recall if nprobe isn't increased proportionally.

Key Takeaway: Vector index configuration is always a compromise—tune HNSW for speed and recall when memory allows, use IVF with quantization when memory is constrained, and measure real performance metrics on your actual data before committing to production settings.