Further Fine-Tuning: Starting from Base or Instruction
What You'll Learn
You'll learn how to decide whether to start your custom fine-tuning from a base model or an instruction-tuned checkpoint.
The Core Decision
When building a custom application, you face an important choice: should you fine-tune from a base model (like GPT-3 base) or from an instruction-tuned model (like GPT-3.5-turbo or ChatGPT)?
Think of it like choosing between two different starting points for a road trip:
- Base model: Starting from a raw highway—you have maximum freedom to go anywhere, but you need to do more navigation work
- Instruction-tuned model: Starting from a guided tour route—easier to follow and modify, but some routes are already preferred
When to Start from Base
Choose a base model when:
- You have large amounts of domain-specific data to fine-tune on
- Your task involves completion or generation without instruction-following
- You want maximum flexibility and don't need instruction-following behavior
- You're doing continued pretraining for domain adaptation before task-specific fine-tuning
When to Start from Instruction-Tuned
Choose an instruction-tuned checkpoint when:
- You have limited training data (few-shot scenarios)
- Your task naturally fits an instruction-response format
- You want the model to maintain general helpfulness while learning your specific task
- You're building conversational or assistant-like applications
The Practical Reality
Starting from instruction-tuned models often requires less data because they've already learned to follow instructions. However, they may be more resistant to learning behaviors that conflict with their safety training or instruction-following patterns.
Key Takeaway: Start from base models when you have substantial domain data and want maximum flexibility; start from instruction-tuned models when you want to preserve helpful, instruction-following behavior with less training data.