When to Use Libraries vs Rolling Your Own
You'll learn: How to decide between using established libraries like lodash.isEqual or fast-deep-equal versus writing your own deep comparison logic.
Now that you've implemented deep equality yourself, you face a practical question: should you use your custom solution or reach for a battle-tested library?
The Case for Libraries
Libraries like lodash.isEqual and fast-deep-equal have been tested across thousands of edge cases you might not even know exist. They handle:
- Obscure built-in types (Map, Set, TypedArrays, Buffers)
- Browser inconsistencies
- Performance optimizations you'd spend weeks perfecting
- Security issues and circular reference edge cases
Think of it like baking bread: you can mill your own flour from wheat, but buying flour from a mill lets you focus on the actual baking.
The Case for Rolling Your Own
Sometimes a custom implementation makes sense:
- Size constraints: Your bundle can't afford 20KB for one function
- Simple needs: You only compare plain objects with known structure
- Learning: Understanding the internals matters for your growth
- Control: You need specific behavior the library doesn't offer
If you only compare {id, name} objects in one place, a 10-line custom function beats importing an entire library.
The Decision Framework
Ask yourself:
- How complex are the values? (simple objects → custom; mixed types → library)
- How critical is correctness? (mission-critical → library)
- What's your bundle budget? (tight → custom or micro-library like
fast-deep-equal) - Will requirements grow? (yes → library provides room to scale)
Key Takeaway: Use libraries when dealing with diverse data types and edge cases; roll your own for simple, controlled scenarios where you understand all inputs and want minimal overhead.