Practical Model Selection Strategy
What you'll learn: How to combine multiple comparison methods into a real-world workflow for choosing the best regression model.
By now, you've learned many tools for comparing models: adjusted R-squared, AIC, BIC, F-tests, cross-validation, and the principle of parsimony. But which one should you use? The answer: use several together.
The Combined Approach
Think of model selection like hiring for a job. You wouldn't hire based on just one criterion (say, years of experience). You'd look at experience, skills, references, and cultural fit. Similarly, use multiple criteria to triangulate toward the best model.
A Practical Workflow
- Start with domain knowledge: Which predictors make theoretical sense?
- Check statistical significance: Use t-tests and F-tests to identify meaningful predictors
- Compare nested models: Use partial F-tests when adding/removing specific variables
- Apply information criteria: Calculate AIC and BIC to balance fit and complexity
- Validate with cross-validation: Ensure the model generalizes to unseen data
- Favor parsimony: When models perform similarly, choose the simpler one (Occam's Razor)
- Check assumptions: Verify residual plots and diagnostics for the final candidate
When Methods Disagree
Sometimes AIC prefers one model while BIC prefers another (BIC penalizes complexity more heavily). In such cases, consider your goal: if prediction is paramount, lean toward cross-validation results. If interpretability matters more, favor the simpler model that still performs well.
Key Takeaway: Model selection isn't about finding one "perfect" metric—it's about synthesizing evidence from statistical tests, information criteria, validation procedures, and domain expertise to make a defensible, practical choice.