Course contentsShow
← Data Science
Lesson 498 of 2,14513. Correlation AnalysisFree lesson

Bradford Hill Criteria for Causation

Apply Bradford Hill's criteria (strength, consistency, temporality, etc.) to assess causal relationships.

Bradford Hill Criteria for Causation

What you'll learn: How to systematically evaluate whether a correlation you've found might represent a true cause-and-effect relationship.

Finding a correlation is exciting—but how do you know if X actually causes Y, or if it's just coincidence, confounding, or reverse causality? British epidemiologist Sir Austin Bradford Hill developed nine criteria to help answer this question. Think of them as a checklist that strengthens (or weakens) your case for causation.

The Nine Criteria

  1. Strength: Strong correlations are more likely causal. If smoking increases lung cancer risk 20-fold, that's harder to explain away than a weak association.

  2. Consistency: Has the relationship been found repeatedly, across different studies, populations, and settings? Replication matters.

  3. Specificity: Does the exposure lead to a very specific outcome (rather than many unrelated effects)?

  4. Temporality: The cause must come before the effect—this is the only non-negotiable criterion. You can't reverse time.

  5. Biological Gradient: Is there a dose-response relationship? More exposure → stronger effect suggests causation.

  6. Plausibility: Does a reasonable mechanism explain how X could cause Y, given current scientific knowledge?

  7. Coherence: Does the causal interpretation align with existing theory and evidence?

  8. Experiment: Can you manipulate the cause and observe the effect change? Experimental evidence is powerful.

  9. Analogy: Are there similar cause-effect relationships already established (e.g., one drug causes birth defects, so a chemically similar drug might too)?

How to Apply Them

No single criterion proves causation—they work together like pieces of evidence in a trial. The more criteria satisfied, the stronger your causal case. Temporality is essential; others add weight.

Key Takeaway: Bradford Hill criteria provide a systematic framework for moving beyond "correlation ≠ causation" to actually assessing whether causation is likely, by examining strength, consistency, temporality, and six other dimensions of evidence.