Consequences of Assumption Violations
You'll learn: How breaking ANOVA's core assumptions undermines your ability to trust test results and draw valid conclusions.
Why Assumptions Matter
ANOVA's three key assumptions—independence, normality, and homoscedasticity—aren't arbitrary rules. They're mathematical requirements that ensure the F-statistic actually follows an F-distribution. When these assumptions break down, the test's statistical guarantees fall apart.
What Goes Wrong
Type I Error Rate Inflation
When homogeneity of variance fails (especially with unequal sample sizes), your nominal α = 0.05 might actually become 0.10 or higher. You'll reject the null hypothesis far more often than intended—finding "significant" differences that don't really exist. It's like a smoke detector that goes off when there's no fire.
Loss of Statistical Power
Violated independence or severe non-normality can reduce your test's ability to detect real differences. You might miss genuine effects because the test has become too noisy or inefficient—like trying to hear a whisper in a windstorm.
Invalid P-Values and Confidence Intervals
When assumptions fail, the p-value you calculate doesn't mean what you think it means. Your confidence intervals may not actually contain the true parameter 95% of the time. The entire inferential framework becomes unreliable.
Biased Effect Size Estimates
Eta-squared and omega-squared can be systematically over- or under-estimated, misleading you about the practical importance of your findings.
The Silver Lining
ANOVA shows some robustness to mild violations, especially with balanced designs and moderate sample sizes. But severe violations demand action: transformations, non-parametric alternatives, or bootstrap methods.
Key Takeaway: Violated ANOVA assumptions corrupt Type I error rates, reduce power, and invalidate p-values—undermining the entire analysis. Always check assumptions before trusting your results.