Choosing Between Parametric and Non-Parametric Tests
You'll learn: How to systematically decide whether to use parametric tests (like t-tests) or non-parametric alternatives (like Wilcoxon or Mann-Whitney) based on your data's characteristics.
The Decision Framework
Think of choosing a statistical test like selecting the right tool from a toolbox. Parametric tests are powerful precision instruments—they work brilliantly if conditions are right. Non-parametric tests are your reliable all-purpose tools—they work in more situations but may be slightly less efficient when conditions are ideal.
The Decision Checklist
Use Parametric Tests (t-tests, ANOVA) when:
- Normality holds: Your data (or sampling distribution) is approximately normal, especially with small samples (n < 30)
- Equal variances: Groups have similar spread (for two-sample tests)
- Interval/ratio data: Meaningful numeric measurements
- Independence: Observations don't influence each other
Switch to Non-Parametric Tests when:
- Normality violated: Severe skewness, outliers, or small samples from non-normal populations
- Ordinal data: Ranks matter, but exact distances don't (e.g., survey ratings)
- Unequal variances: Groups differ dramatically in spread and sample sizes are unequal
- Small samples: Too few observations to assess normality reliably (n < 15-20)
The Practical Workflow
- Check assumptions using visual tools (histograms, Q-Q plots) and tests (Shapiro-Wilk, Levene's)
- Consider robustness: With n > 30-40, t-tests handle mild violations well (Central Limit Theorem)
- Evaluate trade-offs: Parametric tests have higher power when assumptions hold; non-parametric tests are safer when assumptions are questionable
- Match the question: If you care about means, try parametric first. If medians or distributions matter, non-parametric may be more appropriate
Key Takeaway: Choose parametric tests when assumptions are satisfied for maximum power; switch to non-parametric alternatives when assumptions are violated or data is ordinal—but always check your assumptions systematically before deciding.