When to Use Bootstrap vs Traditional Methods
You'll learn: When bootstrap resampling gives you an advantage over traditional parametric methods for confidence intervals.
The Core Question
You've now learned both traditional confidence intervals (using formulas like t-intervals) and bootstrap methods (resampling your data). So when should you use each?
Traditional methods work beautifully when:
- Your statistic has a known formula (like means or proportions)
- You can assume normality (or CLT applies with large samples)
- The math is straightforward
Bootstrap shines when:
- You need confidence intervals for complex statistics (median, correlation, ratio of means, 90th percentile, etc.)
- Your sample size is moderate and you're unsure about distributional assumptions
- The traditional formula is too complicated or doesn't exist
- You're working with real-world messy data that may not meet parametric assumptions
Think of It This Way
Traditional methods are like following a recipe with precise measurements. Bootstrap is like taste-testing as you cook — it adapts to what you actually have.
For a simple mean with normal data? Traditional t-intervals are faster and perfectly fine. But for the difference between two medians? There's no clean formula — bootstrap to the rescue!
Practical Guidelines
Use traditional methods for means and proportions when assumptions hold.
Use bootstrap for:
- Medians, trimmed means, or other robust statistics
- Ratios or complex combinations of parameters
- When normality is questionable and sample size is small-to-moderate
- When you want assumption-free inference
Key Takeaway: Bootstrap offers flexibility for complex statistics where traditional formulas don't exist or assumptions are shaky, while traditional methods remain efficient for simple, well-behaved cases like means and proportions.