Comparing Collision Strategies
What you'll learn: You'll understand the key trade-offs between chaining and open addressing so you can choose the right collision strategy for your hash table.
The Core Trade-Offs
When collisions happen in a hash table, you've learned two main approaches: separate chaining (linking items in lists at each bucket) and open addressing (probing to find another empty slot). Each has distinct performance and memory characteristics.
Performance Considerations
Separate chaining handles high load factors gracefully. Even when your table is full (load factor > 1), operations remain predictable because you're just traversing short linked lists. Search time degrades gradually.
Open addressing performs excellently at low load factors (typically < 0.7). With plenty of empty slots, you find your target quickly. However, as the table fills, clustering causes probe sequences to grow longer, and performance degrades more sharply than chaining.
Memory Trade-Offs
Separate chaining requires extra memory for pointers in each linked list node. If you're storing small data items, these pointers can represent significant overhead. However, the table can hold arbitrarily many items.
Open addressing stores items directly in the table array with no pointer overhead—more cache-friendly and memory-efficient per item. But you're strictly limited by table size and must rehash earlier to maintain performance.
The Practical Choice
Think of chaining like an expandable filing cabinet: each drawer can hold multiple folders that grow as needed. Open addressing is like a fixed parking lot: efficient when half-empty, but frustrating to find a spot when nearly full.
Choose chaining when: load factors might exceed 0.8, memory for pointers is acceptable, or you want predictable performance.
Choose open addressing when: you can keep load factors low, cache performance matters, or pointer overhead is too costly.
Key Takeaway: Separate chaining trades pointer memory for consistent performance at any load factor, while open addressing saves memory but requires lower load factors and earlier rehashing to maintain speed.