Evaluating Design and Architecture
You'll learn how to assess whether code fits existing patterns, maintains proper abstractions, and avoids coupling during code review.
The Architectural Lens
When reviewing code, you're not just checking if it works—you're evaluating how well it fits into the broader system. This means asking three critical questions:
-
Does it follow appropriate patterns? If the codebase uses Strategy Pattern for behavior variation, a new hardcoded
if-elsechain breaks consistency. Pattern adherence keeps the system predictable. -
Are abstractions clean and appropriate? Good abstractions hide complexity without leaking implementation details. If a "database layer" exposes SQL strings to business logic, the abstraction has failed. Think of it like a car's steering wheel—you turn it left or right without knowing about hydraulics or rack-and-pinion mechanisms.
-
Is coupling minimized? Tightly coupled code means changing one module forces changes in many others (Shotgun Surgery smell). Look for unnecessary dependencies—does a payment processor really need to know about UI rendering?
What to Look For
- Pattern violations: New code using Factory Method when existing code uses Abstract Factory for similar purposes
- Abstraction leaks: Implementation details exposed through interfaces
- Hidden dependencies: Classes that know too much about each other's internals
- Architectural boundaries: Does domain logic stay separate from infrastructure concerns?
The goal isn't perfection—it's consistency, clarity, and maintainability. A slightly "imperfect" pattern choice that matches existing conventions beats a "textbook perfect" approach that stands alone.
Key Takeaway: Evaluate code not just for correctness, but for how well it integrates with existing patterns, maintains clean abstractions, and minimizes coupling—these architectural qualities determine long-term maintainability.