Multiple Scaling Policy Coordination
What you'll learn: How Auto Scaling handles situations when multiple scaling policies are active simultaneously and want to scale your resources in different directions.
The Challenge of Multiple Policies
Imagine you've configured both a Target Tracking policy (maintaining CPU at 60%) and a Scheduled Scaling action (adding capacity at 9 AM) on the same Auto Scaling group. What happens when they both trigger at once, possibly recommending different capacities?
How Coordination Works
Auto Scaling uses a "most capacity wins" approach when multiple policies conflict:
- If one policy wants to scale to 5 instances and another wants 8, Auto Scaling chooses 8 instances
- This ensures your application always has enough capacity to meet all requirements
- The system errs on the side of over-provisioning rather than under-provisioning
Common Coordination Scenarios
Conflicting directions: If a Step Scaling policy wants to add capacity while a Scheduled action wants to reduce it, the larger capacity request wins.
Multiple alarms firing: When several target tracking or step scaling policies trigger simultaneously, each calculates its desired capacity independently, and the highest value is selected.
Cooldown interactions: Different policy types may have their own cooldown periods, but they all respect the group's overall cooldown to prevent thrashing.
Why This Matters
This coordination prevents competing policies from fighting each other and causing rapid, wasteful scaling oscillations. It ensures your infrastructure can handle the most demanding requirement at any moment, even when multiple scaling triggers activate together.
Key Takeaway: When multiple Auto Scaling policies conflict, the policy requesting the highest capacity always wins, ensuring your application never lacks the resources it needs.