Trunk-Based vs GitFlow Patterns
What You'll Learn
You'll understand how two fundamental branching strategies—trunk-based development and GitFlow—shape your continuous integration approach and pipeline design.
The Core Difference
Trunk-Based Development means developers commit small, frequent changes directly to a single main branch (the "trunk"). Feature branches, if used at all, are short-lived (hours to a couple of days). Every commit triggers your CI pipeline immediately.
GitFlow uses multiple long-lived branches: a main branch for production, a develop branch for integration, and separate feature branches that may exist for days or weeks. Releases happen through structured branch merging ceremonies.
Pipeline Implications
Trunk-Based Development
- CI runs constantly on every small commit to main
- Tests must be fast and reliable since they block everyone
- Requires feature flags to hide incomplete work in production
- Tight feedback loops: broken builds are everyone's immediate problem
- Deployment happens frequently (true continuous delivery)
GitFlow
- CI runs per feature branch in isolation
- Integration happens later when merging to
develop - Easier to manage large, complex features independently
- Integration conflicts discovered late in the process
- Scheduled releases rather than continuous deployment
Choosing Your Pattern
Trunk-based encourages smaller batch sizes and forces discipline around automated testing. It's ideal for teams practicing continuous deployment with mature DevOps practices.
GitFlow provides structure for teams coordinating multiple versions, managing scheduled releases, or working on features requiring extensive collaboration before integration.
Key Takeaway: Trunk-based development enables true continuous integration with immediate feedback but requires robust testing and feature flags; GitFlow offers structured branching at the cost of delayed integration and slower feedback cycles.