Selecting the Right Index for Your Use Case
What you'll learn: How to choose the optimal vector index by evaluating your dataset size, update frequency, and latency requirements.
The Decision Framework
Choosing the right index isn't about finding the "best" one—it's about finding the best match for your specific constraints. Think of it like choosing transportation: a bicycle is perfect for a quick neighborhood trip, but you'd pick a car for a cross-country journey. Similarly, different indexes excel under different conditions.
Key Decision Criteria
Dataset Size
- Small datasets (< 10K vectors): Flat indexes work fine—brute-force search is fast enough and requires no build time
- Medium datasets (10K-1M vectors): LSH or IVF provide good balance
- Large datasets (> 1M vectors): HNSW or hierarchical approaches become necessary
Update Frequency
- Static or rare updates: Product Quantization (PQ) and IVF shine—their long build times are amortized
- Frequent updates: HNSW supports incremental updates efficiently; avoid indexes requiring full rebuilds
- Real-time streaming: Consider flat indexes with periodic batch rebuilds or HNSW with its update-friendly graph structure
Latency Requirements
- Low-latency, high-recall needs: HNSW provides excellent query speed with tunable recall
- Batch processing acceptable: IVF or PQ can achieve high recall with more computation time
- Memory-constrained environments: PQ reduces memory footprint at the cost of slight accuracy loss
Making the Trade-off
Remember: you're balancing recall, latency, memory, and build time. No index wins on all dimensions. Start by identifying your non-negotiables (e.g., "must handle 100 updates/second" or "must return results in < 10ms"), then select the index that meets those requirements.
Key Takeaway: Choose your vector index based on dataset size, update patterns, and latency needs—not on what's "most popular." Match the tool to your constraints.